on this page

Or send us an email




Application form




Pathways programs

Letters to my students

How-to-do-it guide

Essay archive

Ask a philosopher

Pathways e-journal

Features page

Downloads page

Pathways portal



Pathways to Philosophy
Home



Geoffrey Klempner CV
G Klempner



International Society for Philosophers
ISFP site







PHILOSOPHY PATHWAYS electronic journal

[home]


P H I L O S O P H Y   P A T H W A Y S                   ISSN 2043-0728
http://www.philosophypathways.com/newsletter/

Issue number 165
13th September 2011

CONTENTS

I. 'Narcissus and Melancholy' by Matthew Del Nevo

II. Matthew Del Nevo 'The Work of Enchantment' Reviewed by Rachel
Browne

III. 'Sexopoly: Beckoning into Abyss' by Stephen Farthing MNCP

-=-

EDITOR'S NOTE

There is no shortage of explanations on the part of philosophers --
those who following Nietzsche grandly style themselves 'physicians of
culture' -- for the present state of our cultural fallenness. It is
less common to find thinkers who are prepared to stick their necks
out and advocate a remedy. Matthew Del Nevo's new book, The Work of
Enchantment offers, in the author's words, 'a philosophy of culture
which crosses between psychoanalysis, social-critical theory and
literature.' To make good the ground we have lost, the corrosion of
modern consumerist culture, requires dedicated work on the part of
each and every one of us who cares about the state of our 'soul'.

According to Del Nevo, it is through art, and in particular poetry,
that our salvation lies.

Alongside an extract from Del Nevo's book we have a review by Rachel
Browne who comments on the book's relevance to recent events in the
news, as well as defending the author against the suspicion of
elitism. The point of the book would be lost if Del Nevo was merely
preaching to the converted.

Fitting with the theme of cultural critique, Stephen Farthing, a
Member of the National Council of Psychotherapists offers his searing
observations of a society in the process of becoming an all-engulfing
'sexopoly', where existential anxiety and the fear of death manifests
itself as an increasing obsession with sexuality and the body,
reducing human beings to objects and destroying the meaning of human
relationships.

Geoffrey Klempner

-=-

I. 'NARCISSUS AND MELANCHOLY' BY MATTHEW DEL NEVO

Lou Salome was the daughter of an aristocratic general in the court
of Tsar Alexander II; she traveled in Europe; spoke Russian, German,
French, and Italian fluently; wrote 20 books and many articles.
Nietzsche's best friend, Paul Ree, was in love with her in Rome, when
he wrote to Nietzsche, who he believed to be in Genoa, and asked him
to join them. Nietzsche was just turning toward all that he would
become in his own inner life and ours. He had left Genoa for Messina,
where the letter eventually reached him. He caught up with Ree and Lou
in Rome. He fell in love with her too. They formed a menage-a-trois.
Her idea. A 'holy trinity' they called it. 

Nietzsche read 'The Madman' aphorism to them at Rome, part of the
book that he would publish as The Gay Science, in which, in the
aphorism I am speaking of, a madman declares in the marketplace that
God is dead, God remains dead, and that we have killed him. A capital
philosophical text in the history of modern thought. Nietzsche, no
womanizer, believed Lou to be his intellectual peer, and discussed
his ideas with her. He proposed marriage several times, only to be
rejected. Lou wrote the first book on Nietzsche's work, which is
still one of the best books on Nietzsche, around whom now flourishes
a whole academic publishing industry.

In 1911, Lou met Freud, a man who was rewriting philosophy in terms
of the soul of the individual. Freud had discovered something people
were largely unconscious of, which he called 'sexuality.' This
quality of the soul, he thought, was definitional for what went on
between people, for the points of coalescence and demarcation, for
the dynamics of every relationship, and it affected inner thought
including philosophical thought. Lou had already in 1910 published a
book entitled Eroticism. She and Freud were very much on the same
page, as it were. Lou was a legend in intellectual circles in Europe,
including Freud's. Lou had known Nietzsche, Wagner, and Tolstoy; she
knew Rilke, Strindberg, Buber, Hofmenstahl, Hauptmann, and Scheler.
Her biographer writes: 'A female Faust she was not interested in
rummaging in empty words. She wanted to 'detect the inmost force that
binds the world and guides its course,' she wanted to know it, to
experience it, to live it.'

Lou and Freud had already set their sails to the same course before
they ever met. Of all the great men she met, Freud was the first who
stopped Lou in her tracks. She recognized a teacher and mentor, and a
reverse situation took place for the first time in her life: she fell
under his spell. And he did not, like so many of the others, succumb
to her charms, although he recognized and even revered her
intellectual versatility and insight. She moved to Vienna and
enrolled in his lectures. And then she worked with him at the
inception of psychoanalysis; a student, but also a colleague, she
helped to bring Freud's soulful science about.

According to her 1910 book Eroticism, Lou speaks of Narcissus as a
germinal soul-story as, at the core of narcissism, there is a tension
between self-love and self-surrender. In the Greek myth, Narcissus
looks into the water, looks into the depths. He sees his reflection
gaze back at him rather than the depths; he sees not just himself,
but the trees and the sky -- nature, in short. He sees his own face
and sees it in nature. He does not just see himself, but himself
against the backdrop of nature. Lou asks: 'Does not his face express
melancholy as well as enchantment?' Enchantment, because he is
delighted with what he sees, especially with the sight of himself.
Melancholy, because he is estranged from what he sees; he senses his
exile, even with regard to himself. This is important. Enchantment is
coupled with melancholy.

Melancholy is the mood in which the soul is made ready to become
sensitized. Melancholy 'opens' the soul, lays it bare. Melancholy, we
are sensitive. We are not sad, we are not despondent. These are a
different music. We are not depressed. Then we cannot hear the music.
Melancholy is none of these. We do not induce melancholy. As the poet
Keats says, in his famous Ode on Melancholy, 'But when a melancholy
fit shall fall/ Sudden from heaven like a weeping cloud...'
Melancholy falls, and from heaven. In other words, it is good,
beneficent, and heaven-sent. It moistens the soul, like soil is
moistened if what is rooted there should grow. But here, what is to
grow is our inwardness. Melancholy is a mood we fall into. It takes
us by surprise. It 'takes' us, in the full biblical sense of the
ravished bride that is 'taken.'

In Freud's language melancholy is sexual, in the sense of a general
unawakened languishing as a ground-mood of existence -- in contrast
to awakened sexuality, which is creative and wants to give birth. In
ordinary language, melancholy is a mood. But it is not a mood in the
temperamental sense in which, perhaps, I wake up 'on the wrong side
of the bed' in a bad mood; or, alternatively, in which, 'I am happy
as Larry.' Melancholy is a ground-mood in the sense that, according
to the philosopher Martin Heidegger, anxiety and boredom are, because
the way we 'deal' with time opens out from these ground-moods, or
closes back into them if we are not careful. A ground-mood is a mood
as close as possible or as imaginable to the experience of our naked
being or to the intimacy of our solitude. A ground-mood is a basic
condition of 'experience.' Melancholy does not center the self but
opens it for the possibility of determination, and melancholy has the
effect of making the self extremely vulnerable. This is when, if the
mind is like antennae, the antennae are at a fever pitch of
receptivity.

Melancholy is also, traditionally, related to our exile. In this
world we know what ought to be the case: justice and mercy. And we
can see we exist apart from a world where these reign. As Levinas
puts it: 'And love means, before all else, the welcoming of the other
as thou. Can that welcome be carried out empty-handed?' We know what
heaven is like: it is a place of harmony where good prevails; and we
know this earth is not like that: 'And after this our exile' said
T.S. Eliot, who recalled all this about melancholy and exile in Ash
Wednesday, 1930 so perfectly. We know our job (if we know anything)
is to make this world conform more to how things ought to be. And yet
we get sidetracked and forget, or stuck in a never-ending argument.
Even relations in our own world are a mess and their fate, perhaps,
out of our control; how much more impossible other relationships
then! Melancholy is related to realism. Every realistic novel is a
melancholy affair and every death-bed scene. Melancholy can easily
sink to darker, more confining moods, which are not from heaven. To
avoid this dire fate we must know what the poets and artists down the
ages have to tell us. This is what the humanities used to teach. If we
sink into darker moods we cannot become initiated into the beauty,
depth, joy, and aching pleasure that the melancholy fit portends.

Enchantment presupposes melancholy, as Lou Salome perhaps was first
to theorize in her work on the erotic, and as Rilke would show in his
poetry. We are not really part of things in the sense of 'that
openness that is so deep in the animal's vision,' as Rilke wrote, for
'we never have that pure space in front of us, nor for a single day,
such as flowers open endlessly into' (Eighth Elegy). Self-love and
self-surrender at the heart of our being -- our 'sexuality' --
confines us within the world, within the human. 'Always,' Rilke
wrote, for us 'there is world, and never the Nowhere without the Not:
the pure/ unwatched-over, that one breathes and endlessly knows,
without craving' (Eighth Elegy).

 This extract from The Work of Enchantment is reproduced with kind
 permission of Transaction Publishers, New Jersey USA.
 http://www.transactionpub.com.

Matthew Del Nevo
Senior Lecturer in Philosophy
Catholic Institute of Sydney
http://www.cis.catholic.edu.au

E-mail: mdelnevo@cis.catholic.edu.au

-=-

II. MATTHEW DEL NEVO 'THE WORK OF ENCHANTMENT' REVIEWED BY RACHEL
BROWNE

The Work of Enchantment
By Matthew Del Nevo
Transaction Publishers, New Jersey, 2011

Matthew Del Nevo is a philosopher at the Catholic Institute of
Sydney. The book falls within social theory but is mainly an example
of philosophical reading of literature. It laments the soullessness
of the world; it's increasing banality and the increasing influence
of the culture industries and commodification of ever more areas of
our lives, including education. The 'work' of enchantment is
identified as reading, listening and gazing. These seem unimportant
in today's culture, but this soulful activity, which Del Nevo calls
'enchantment' is counter-cultural. He attacks modern day culture
while examining some works by Proust, Rilke and Goethe, and sets this
literary investigation against the background of Adorno's philosophy.

Enchantment is written to be accessible to those outside philosophy
(dependent on whether they are able to read, I suppose). Del Nevo
states that he is aware of sounding elitist, but says that he doesn't
mean to be so. You can't help but believe him and he is actually
addressing cultural problems in as honest a way as possible. The book
is also a defence of the humanities over technological and vocational
education, which abounds in these materialistic times. Del Nevo takes
the strong view that enchantment has actually been lost from the
humanities. He doesn't make quite clear why this is, but his choice
of writers to look at in this book suggests that these writers are
deeper than contemporary literature, film and art, which is studied.

The philosophy here is a philosophy of life, not a systematic
philosophy. For instance, Del Nevo shows, through looking at a work
by Marcel Proust that 'within an enchanted life death loses its
sting.' (p.35). It is wisdom literature.

Del Nevo's analysis of Proust makes me feel I should have paid more
attention when I read him years ago. He describes Swann becoming
infatuated with Odette in Remembrance of Things Past. The nature of
the metaphysical experience of falling in love in this case is
described as 'aesthetic', in that Swann comes to see Odette in a new
light as he falls in love with her and comes to regard her as
beautiful. Proust might not have been aware of engaging in aesthetics
when he describes this.

But it is also shown that the novel embodies a philosophy of
language. It is found that in Proust there is an understanding that
we don't just 'use' language and that it is not a mere tool. Words
are not neutral. Swann receives an anonymous letter telling him that
Odette has been engaged in licentious sexual behaviour, and this too
changes him. He became soulful when he fell in love, but when he
received the letter, it was soul destroying. The words in the letter
had the power to change Swann. I suppose it is to be assumed that a
writer would be aware of the power of words, but I wonder if Proust
had explicit knowledge that he held a theory of language?

But Del Nevo doesn't ignore theory. According to Adorno, philosophy
from Plato on to Hegel was concerned with conceptuality, ideas and
generality (Of course this was how philosophy was before Plato too),
but this was turned on it's head by Marx, Nietzsche and Freud, who
were more concerned with psychology, sociology and detail. It seems
that Proust, Rilke and Goethe also rejected Hegelianism by
concentrating on the trivial and the particular. It is by this means
of the grip of recognising the psychology presenting and meanings
that trivia have for us that we are entering another 'world', which
is denied to us by grand systems.

Time is an undercurrent of the book. The aesthetic theory that a work
of art is that which passes the Test of Time, as posited by Anthony
Savile and others, is an aesthetic theory that Del Nevo seems to
subscribe to. He says that an 'artwork can speak diachronically,
across time, to a time of its own' and that the 'optimum example is
those writings regarded by our culture such as Scriptures'.

It seems that Goethe's Faust is MORE relevant now than when Goethe
wrote it. It has more than passed the test of time. It seems
prophetic. Parallels are drawn between Faust's pact with
Mephistopheles and modernity, which is out of control and subject to
external forces. Mephistopheles had hold over Faust, but eventually
Faust comes to see that pleasure-seeking and worldliness are
disenchanting. We can only hope this is prophetic if we find
modernity spiralling out of control.

Just a warning to atheists! This is a philosopher who teaches in a
theological institute, who is theologically informed and so uses
metaphorical language of the soul, heaven and angels. This should not
put you off. I'm an atheist and it didn't put me off. This is not a
religious book and actually notes that the soul is not to be confused
with the spirit, which is the religious concept. This distinction can
be found in Rilke. The soul is about humanity, recognition of depth,
being able to appreciate art, and finding resonance in things.
Things, or objects, are held to be important in this book. The poets
discussed are particularly interested in how some things resonate
with us -- real things, names of real things that have the ability to
arouse feeling in us -- not brand names.

I take it that properly this book is about the inner life; of our
ability to be captivated by things; about being enchanted in contrast
to the modern obsession with economics and technological
communication. It doesn't fit neatly into the modern world of mobile
phones and twittering and at times the author seems to apologise for
what he is writing about. Such apology has been made before, by the
Jewish philosopher, Emmanuel Levinas, who is quoted as having said
'The inner life: One is almost ashamed to pronounce this pathetic
expression in the face of so many realisms and objectivisms' (p22).

I write this review shortly after the riots in England, which
occurred in London, Birmingham and several other cities and towns.
This is also shortly after English pop singer Amy Winehouse was
discovered dead. Although unfashionable to write about enchantment,
this book is relevant to the modern world. Of technology, Del Nevo
suggests that 'we become the unwitting tools of our own tools'. Del
Nevo believes that capitalism often provides 'delusory substitutes
for enchantment' (p.13), such as glamour, and that even violence can
be taken to be glamorous. This certainly seems to have been the case
in the recent riots. Those involved were unable to see the reality of
destruction and harm to others. Furthermore they were seeking glamour
by looting for designer goods in many cases. Del Nevo also claims
that celebrities 'lead glamorous lives which, very often, are totally
disenchanted' (p.13). The sad case of Amy Winehouse immediately comes
to mind. There are truths to be found in this book which many would
not like to voice for fear of sounding superior.

Since enchantment, listening and gazing are about absorption -- in
art, philosophy, and religion (some forms of science are not
excluded) -- this book won't appeal to those who twitter and text and
probably would bring remorse to the friends of Amy Winehouse. But
really it is these people to whom the book should be addressed. An
interesting question is whether the book would have rapport with such
people. Del Nevo defines the soul as that which refers to 'the
unity... of our inner sensibilities and sensitivities' (p.23).
Soulfulness and enchantment are about our inner life. Everyone has an
inner life in this sense, unless seriously ill, so enchantment is
about the quality of that inner life.

Enchantment, or being captivated, and having 'metaphysical
experience' (Adorno's term, which Del Nevo uses) is of physical, not
just social, importance. We need to take note of the warnings that
this book brings to us.

(c) Rachel Browne 2011

E-mail: RachelEBrowne@aol.com

-=-

III. 'SEXOPOLY: BECKONING INTO ABYSS' BY STEPHEN FARTHING MNCP

Existential psychotherapy has its roots in finding meaning, and how
meaning is experienced within one's relationship to others, and in
relationship to one's self. Whereas the psychodynamic school of
thought centres itself on drives, drive reduction and conflict
between the psyche, the behaviourist on acquired learning around
stimuli and response, and the cognitive therapist on faulty and
inaccurate thinking, the existentialist philosopher grounds his work
on being a being, and on being a being in the world. From a
biological paradigm, life has a natural flow of coming into
existence, then of replication of itself, followed by withering,
decay and death. Within the existential paradigm, we think in terms
of non-being, then becoming a some-thing, and returning to non-being
as a no-thing. Every person as a some-thing, has to locate themselves
in relation to other some-things who are in a state of being at the
same point of existence. This paper will explore the theme of the
implosion of sexuality and its increasing absorption into our
society, and relate this within an existential paradigm of socially
mediated defence against anxiety of ultimate concerns.

As Spinelli (2005, p 113) points out we as a some-thing, along with
other some-things, are part of 'a particular body, a particular time,
a particular culture, a particular set of prevailing socio-cultural
attitudes and more, stances and opinions.' In this article I am
addressing the issue of being and becoming a some-thing-that contains
a sexual element as an interregnal experience of being. Social
discourse and meditation craft and shape our experience of
being-in-the-world, with sexuality bridging the anxieties of death,
freedom, isolation and meaninglessness.

Jennifer is 24, white, a brunette of British origin. She is 5' 3",
bisexual, a non-smoker, has a tattoo and but no piercings. During the
day Jennifer is works in an office as an administration manager and is
described as outgoing and comfortable in social situations. There are
four photographs of Jennifer, one in an evening gown, another sitting
on a swing in jeans and an T-shirt, and two others. Nicky is described
as a blond, 5' 6", and size 10. Nicky is a social smoker, has good
conversational English, and is very popular. Sam is described as a
redhead, with the fiery personality that you would expect. Sam is
bisexual, aged 26, and has both piercings and tattoos. She is central
European, enjoys both theatre and clubbing and is very good company.
There are a number of photographs of Sam in various poses. Although
these descriptions could be thought of as being presented by an
introduction agency, they can in fact be seen on the Internet by
simply clicking an on-screen button that says you are over 18, and
asks no further questions.

The photographs of Sam show her in different styles of clothing, from
a long dress ready for an evening out at the theatre, to her crouching
down nude leaning up against a wall, while looking into the camera
lens. All three girls in fact appear in the galleries of different
London escort agencies. Each agency promises a professional and
discreet service, but also points out that the fees payable are for
the ladies time and that anything else that occurs is solely between
two consenting adults. Such agencies can now be found all over the
United Kingdom. Over the years, such agencies have become more
confident in their existence, with many now offering on-line booking
forms for appointments and credit card payments. With growing
boldness, some of these agencies now state what sexual services are
on offer from each of the women by using various abbreviations.

In addition to the agencies, there is a significant number of
'independent ladies' with their own web-sites, along with a number of
directories. Caroline in the Midlands tells you that she does not mind
travelling to London, and that she has been driving since the age of
17 so driving distances to hotels is fine. The web sites along with
their booking terms and arrangements for both in-call and out-call
visiting, present escorting as a sophisticated, glamorous, and a
social acceptable activity. Such web sites are a form of Weird
Science in which the potential user can go through the galleries and
find the perfect women for themselves [1]. The galleries are mere
catalogues of 'objectified' female bodies.

Many of the Internet based agencies also carry reviews that consist
of feedback from those who have made appointments with escorts. One
independent web site consists of large numbers of such reviews about
both escorts and various agencies. The feedback details include
dates, locations, and the experience of the appointment.

However, there is no need to go on-line looking for such agencies. A
local free paper that is available each week on a Friday in
newsagents, outside garages, in pubs and on display stands, contains
among others under personals an advert that states 'Hot Angel.
Stunning & Upmarket. New Ladies. Luxury Flat. Quality Time.' The same
edition of this free advertising based paper has an advertisement that
seeks to attract new escorts, both female and male, with the prospect
of high earnings.

The television series, Secret Diaries of a Call Girl was broadcast
between 2010 and 2011. The storyline follows the character Hannah
Baxter (played by the actress Billie Piper), who comes from an
average middle-class background and is a successful university
graduate living in London. Unknown to her family Hannah is a high
class call girl (Belle) with expensive tastes in living, having
attempted a number of professional roles she has difficultly is
settling down to a career. The television series was based on the
real life of Dr. Brooke Magnanti, who supplemented her doctoral
research by working as an escort between 2003 and 2004. Brooke
Magnanti published two books about her life, Belle de Jour: The
Intimate Adventures of a Call Girl (2005), and The Further Adventures
of a London Call Girl (2006), which both became UK top ten best
sellers. Dr. Magnanti, revealed her real name and profession as a
child health scientist in 2009 fearing that her real identity would
be discovered. Her original internet blogs attracted millions of
readers around the world.[2]

Pornography, including material which refers to images of prostitutes
is widely available in the United Kingdom. Such material is stocked by
family orientated retailers such as WH Smith, newsagents, and garages
throughout the country. One suburban local shop called Oswell's
stocks basic groceries and provisions, with a long top shelf crammed
with different titles of pornographic magazines (of which there are
500 titles in circulation). Digital has seen the arrival of
Television X; a subscription site to pornography. In 2007 Television
X set up Television X WebTV. This followed censorship rules that did
not apply to this and allowed Television X to show hardcore content
to its viewers for the first time. In 2008 Television X established
Television X.com following an Ofcom ruling that prohibited the
advertising of explicit sexual material on television. However the
promotion of soft pornography remains permissible.

More recently the Freeview Channel Babestation was launched where
topless women can be watched gyrating while they receive private
telephone calls on a premium rate number from viewers. Babestation
first broadcast in 2002, and is one of a new type of televised sex
line. Babestation became so profitable that it duration of time on
air was doubled. Increased expansion on the adult section of Freeview
channels includes a station called Blue, and another called Filth.

Predecessors such as Channel Four's Euro Trash and Virgin Televisions
Sextextra programmes perhaps paved the way and edged towards the
increasing sexual material available on television. Eurotrash was a
programme produced by Rapido Television and shown on Channel Four
from 1993. Eurotrash was watched by 2-3 million viewers every week.
Channel Four's average number of viewers for Eurotrash was around
900,000 people, making the show a significant and popular broadcast
for the channel. It is no longer unusual for a television announcer
to offer a warning that 'the following program contains scenes of a
sexual nature' before the start of broadcast.

Asterburn & March (2007), note that there are 400 million pages of
pornography on the Internet, and that 25% of daily searches on
internet 'engines' are for such sites. This accounts for sixty-eight
million searches each day. They also note that according to Family
Safe Media, the greatest consumer group of internet pornography is
boys between the age of twelve and seventeen. The average age of a
boy looking at internet pornography for the first time is at the age
of eleven. Under the MySpace.com category of Romance and
Relationships, the two most popular user groups are, Sexy Live
Webcams Room and, Sexy Kittens Group. During the first week of being
established on the internet, the Sexy Kittens Group had 30,000 people
signing up, with the Sexy Live Webcams Room having had 93,000 people
sign up to its site.

The Internet site YouTube has also become a platform for people who
want to broadcast activities of a sexual nature. Uploads of both
heterosexual and gay encounters are easily downloaded from YouTube
either on the Internet or by using Smart Phones. It can be seen that
there is no shortage of people willing to display their sexualised
behaviour to the world. The recent activity of 'sexting' has become a
new platform of sexual display using mobile telephones, particularly
among young people. The extent to which sexting takes place is
notable.

The following statistics are taken from CosmoGirl and the National
Campaign to Prevent Teen Pregnancy, 2009:

     22% of teen girls and 20% of teen boys have sent nude or
     semi-nude photos of themselves over the Internet or their
     phones.
     
     22% of teens admit that technology makes them personally
     more forward.
     
     38% of teens say exchanging sexy content makes dating or
     hooking up with others more likely.
     
     29% of teens believe those exchanging sexy content are
     'expected' to date or hook up.[3]
     
In June 1995, the British actor Hugh Grant was arrested and charged
with indecent conduct in the United States having approached Divine
Brown, a 23 year old prostitute on Sunset Boulevard. Wayne Rooney,
the Manchester United and England Team football player, has also been
involved with prostitutes. In his autobiography Rooney writes that he
had visited a brothel at the age of 16. In his book Rooney wrote that
he was not saying his actions were right, but that he felt it was the
type of thing lads do when they are hanging around, eating chips and
what 'lads' do for a laugh. However, since the original story came
under press attention in 2004, Jennifer Thompson has made fresh
claims around Rooney's involvement with prostitutes. Alistair
Campbell, before becoming a parliamentarian and previously working
for the Daily Mirror, was employed by the pornographic magazine Forum
to write erotic stories. In an interview with journalist Vanessa
Thorpe, Alistair Campbell told her that he wrote erotic material
'purely for a laugh... and too see what effect it had' (Thorpe, 2010).

Rooney's comments that his behaviour was simply something that lads
do for a laugh, along with those of Alistair Campbell can be seen
through the concept of banal interpretation. Banal interpretation is
a casual comment that describes something seen as ordinary (Willig,
2011). As philosophers and existential therapists, how do we make
sense of the experience of being, and being-in-the-world relating to
both the increasingly normality of overt presence of sexual display
available on the Internet, in newspapers, and on television, along
with the open promotion of sexual interaction in the form of escorts,
chat lines, erotic dancing and lap dancing clubs, and web-based sites
such as Elicit Encounters which links married people who are seeking
an affair or sexual encounter?

Terms such as the sexual revolution and sexual liberation are seen by
the existentialist as a banal interpretation, for the philosopher and
existentialist there is further and significant thought beyond the
banal. The banal interpretation itself may find its roots in the
consumerist age in which our culture finds itself. The human body,
particularly the female body, is now evoked as a prized consumer
object. Jean Baudrillard notes in regard to the body that:

     It's 'rediscovery,' in a spirit of physical and sexual
     liberation, after a millennial age of puritanism; its
     omnipresence... in advertising, fashion and mass culture;
     the hygienic, dietetic, therapeutic cult which surrounds
     it, the obsession with youth, elegance, virility/
     femininity, treatments and regimes, and sacrificial
     practices attaching to it all bear witness to the fact that
     the body has become an object of salvation,. It has
     literally taken over that moral and ideological function
     from the soul. (Baudrillard, 2009a)
     
The body is today experienced as an object to be embraced, to be
invested in and indulged, but also an object to be feared. Both male
and female are called upon to botox and detox, to 'make over' and in
the consumerist culture reinvent itself. The body itself is taken as
a product that in a highly competitive consumer culture, is required
to reduce the aging process and delay the inevitability of decay and
death. The female body is required as an imperative to stay beautiful
and young, while the male becomes distinguished, is required to remain
virile and potent. For the women, her body is an unquestionably an
asset linked to success. This has created a huge economy in fashion,
health products, beauty and anti-ageing creams, and gymnasiums and
fitness models such as palettes in addition to health farms and
beauty salons. Baudrillard (2009b) states that the body has become
the finest consumer object. The body for Baudrilllard has become the
new soul and taken over its function.

The concept of the body being an object for the consumption of others
is noted by Urry in relation to sustaining:

     The modern tourist resort is in many respects organised
     around the idea of visual consumption and this involves the
     body itself becoming an object -- while on holiday people
     display their bodies in ways that are quite different from
     what they might do at home. The suntan has become a
     significant part of this visual consumption. (Urry, J, 1990)
     
The female body can be seen therefore as both object and product. As
both object and product, the body becomes an item which requires
investment, but can also be coupled to wider images of the consumer
society. It follows that the body is an economic asset for the
promotion of affluent material life style. Linked to this consumer
culture of beauty, is that of the erotic, with its fantasy and
illusion. The contemporary escort and pornographer have capitalized
on the asset of the body as object and product. Hard core
pornography, easily available on the internet, signifies the final
fallacy and disfigurement and objectification of the body,
particularly the female body. It is however a disfigurement that has
its form within existential anxieties. The chaos of such anxieties
involving expression through the sexual body can be seen in Salvador
Dali's 1966 drawing 'Scene Erotique a Sept Personnages'.

The natural next step from consumerism is that of competitiveness.
Bauman (2007 p82) notes the pressure and demand of the consumer 'to
be and to stay ahead' (ahead of the 'style pack' -- that is, of the
reference group, of the significant others,' the 'others who count'
and whose approval or rejection draws the line between success and
failure.)' The social mediation of the body and sexual activity is
constantly fed by women's magazines. Cosmopolitan (Sept 2011),
carried the front cover theme of 'Win the Sex Factor -- The hottest
moves his ex didn't know.' The message here is clear. The reader
needs to be better then her predecessor, she has to be a new improved
version for him. In the same month, Glamour, which claims to be
Britain's No1 Women's Magazine, had a front cover stating 'What sex
feels like... with a movie star, in a threesome, when he's a virgin.
(You know you're curious).' The message tells the reader that she
ought to be curious, and her interest is enticed. Barker (2011) notes
that 'Despite societal shifts, women are still encouraged to objectify
their bodies, as passports to love and happiness... the mechanisms of
this have simply become more slippery and difficult to identify in
these days of postmodern irony and media saturation.'

The movie, Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging (2008), tells the story
of 14 year old Georgia moving up the 'snogging scale' as she
negotiates her way through adolescence. A scene in this movie aimed
at young people, shows the main character going to a boy for snogging
lessons. Subtle as it may be; it mediates and normalises the message
that again is rooted in consumerism and perfection of the body.
Georgia must perform kissing perfectly; she must get it right if she
is to get her dream boyfriend. But not only get kissing right, she is
14 years old with her birthday soon, so the pressure is there to do it
now.

Another film has the following scene. Three girls at a private
school, seemingly in the 6th form, are standing in a room that has
the presentation of a theatre dressing room. The girls are wearing
little clothing with one in just underwear. Two of the girls are
making up the third while she sits in front of a mirror when the
telephone rings. The telephone is answered with the words 'posh
totties,' as two young children in school uniform are hushed out of
the room. The actress greets the caller with the words 'hello big
boy.' The caller's voice is never heard but a further response from
the actress is that she is wearing her school uniform but is changing
into her gym kit. This is followed in a seductive voice by the line 'I
did really well in my last oral, although I did find it a bit of a
mouthful at first, but miss says that if I practice as often as I can
I could become head girl.' (St. Trinnian's, 2007) The scene reflects a
liberalisation in innuendo. Both Angus, Thongs & Perfect Snogging, and
St. Trinnian's were passed by censors as being appropriate for twelve
year old children.

Below sexual liberalisation where the body has become a fine consumer
'object' there lies existential anxiety at deepest levels. The present
consumer culture is a cover forming a defence against existential
anxieties. Consumerism hides innate death and isolation anxiety. All
the time that people are buying, increasing, building and extending
their material world, improving and making life over, an illusion of
moving away from decay and death is created. It is a great
distraction from existential death anxiety. One's own body takes part
in this illusion with the ever increasing need to stay looking younger
and thus ward off the reality off death. Existential isolation anxiety
is also warded off through sexuality and the liberalisation of
attitudes and behaviour (which also brooches existential freedom
anxiety).

Hanby (2000) makes an interesting comment alluding to existential
anxiety of meaninglessness:

     The culture of death is simultaneously a culture dominated
     by the notion of 'entertainment.'... The very notion of
     entertainment presumes the state of boredom as the norm,
     which means that a culture increasingly fuelled by the
     notion assumes that our lives are innately and
     intrinsically meaningless without constant stream of
     stimulation and distraction, a stream inevitably subject to
     the law of diminishing return.
     
Hanby expresses the view that in the Western World humanity is living
within a culture that causes the death of authentic relationships and
living. It is the death of meaning and being comfortable with ones
finite place in the universe. We are busy 'keeping our mind off' the
realities of our transient existence and inability to make sense of
it and ground our lives.

Crichton (2000) also points towards underlying anxiety when he notes
that the uppermost and overriding demand from people is that of
distraction. He points out that in all fields from commerce to
government, marketing and sales to education, that entertainment has
become the dominant mode. Sexuality is a very large entertainment
field that provides such distracting entertainment. When we are being
entertained, we are again distracted from away from our existential
anxieties of death, isolation and meaninglessness. Sexuality has
become a mode of existential defence against ultimate concerns of
existence.

In thinking about existential meaninglessness, Maimonides (1963)
highlights four possible ways to address existential meaningless. He
begins with the course of gaining perfection of physical possessions,
but rejects this as materialism is imaginary and an impairment to
human growth. His next course is that of the perfection of the human
body, but sees this as neglecting to acknowledge the difference
between animals and the human being. His third course is that of
moral perfection, but rejects this as it only serves others and
denies the 'self.' He chooses his fourth course, which is that of
rational perfection. This is defined as true human perfection where
man becomes man. This comic existentialism is the only meaningful
course as it allows man to comprehend the existence of God. Both
consumerism and the body as an object can be seen in Maimonides's
first two courses. The third course is sacrificial in that it denies
the individual, with the fourth course as a being-in-the-world and
being-there-for-others standpoint.

Martin Buber's well known thoughts on the I-thou and I-It is
particularly relevant. However, an argument for an I-thee could be
presented. The I-It would be experienced within the self relating to
object, with the I-Thou relating to two sets of self (a one and an
other). The I-thee is a more familiar, but is less attuned than the
I-thou. The experience between escort and client could however be
seen in terms of an It-It relationship. The escort turns his or her
client into an 'It,' and the client does the same. This is the great
illusion, a deceit to ward off and defend the self against
existential anxieties.

But this can also be true of many other relationships; those that are
perceived to be I-thou but barely make the I-thee. A consumer mind and
life that is in constant tension and competition with others has
little time for authentic I-thou relationships, so the self may gorge
on the I-It with all underlying existential awareness unknown. The
inner life of the self is dismissed out of mind, and relationships
with others, particularly in relation to the body become vulgarised.
People become mere tools or equipment of another. This can be seen in
current web sites that link people seeking 'no strings attached' and
casual sexual experience. The contemporary term of 'friends with
benefits' is another example of human relationships becoming diluted
in the attempt of the self to ward off isolation anxiety. An
increased number of casual sexual encounters, being lived out or
imagined, become increased material capital.

According to Buber's account of an existentially aware relationship,

     The basic experiential mode of the I-Thou is 'dialogue,' in
     which, either silently or spoken, 'each of the participants
     has in mind the other or others in their particular being
     and turns to them with the intention of establishing a
     living mutual relation between himself and them.'
     (Yallom, I, 1980)
     
To fend off existential anxiety, materialism & consumerism along with
the competitiveness that follows; the body and sexuality having being
given a prime position in social mediation, a synthetic sense of
being and being-in-the-world is experienced. Society is failing to
face questions of ultimate existential concern. For the existential
psychotherapists, the fear of addressing and accepting the
existential realities of our existence lies behind not only
pathology, but the human condition in general and in the shaping of
our present culture. Our society and our inner selves are absorbing
socially mediated sexuality that leaves the 'self' and relationship
with other's 'self' as a caricature of humanity. New words in our
sexualised society such as vanilla, friends with benefits and so
forth, further sediment sexual liberalisation and increase the very
anxiety that it is trying to reduce and avoid.

The mathematical, scientific and terrestrial mind is blinded to the
existential anxieties that lie behind unexplained behaviour and
actions. Isolation anxiety is not mere loneliness, but an
a-lone-ness, being severed and extracted from all that exists.
Primary anxieties that are not embraced and dealt with become a
vortex within the mantle of the human soul and bodies crust. Rogers
(1989) gives the  illustration of a metal pen that is not as solid as
it appears. A metal pen, which feels solid, is made up of invisible
atoms that move at great speed. Every atom however is made up of a
nucleus, and that itself is made up of other particles. There is much
speed and movement with the metal pen.

This paper has highlighted the theme of the gradual and unnoticed
sexuality and its increasing Sexopoly (absorption) into our society,
and related this within an existential paradigm. Yallom (1980) notes
that death anxiety... freedom, isolation and meaninglessness... all
four represent strands in the cable of existence and all must
eventually be recombined into a unified existential model of
psychotherapy. Slowly, there is a beckoning into the abyss as each
'I' avoids the 'Thou' and avoids opening the deep well of mutual
existential discovery.

The existential psychotherapist in their casework conceptualisation
is aware of the manifestation of the ultimate concerns of death
anxiety (returning to non-being), freedom (fear of autonomy),
isolation (being alone and without connectedness), and
meaninglessness (life having no reason, validity or purpose). The
therapist is aware of how these underlying ultimate concerns can be
seen in today's consumer world view, with its along-siding
competitiveness, and the sexopoly that is, beyond our awareness,
enticing and beckoning the self into the abyss of anxiety. Sexopoly
makes the seen become unseen.

 Notes

1. 'Weird Science', a 1985 movie written and directed by John Huge
and staring Anthony Michael Hall, Ilan Mitchell-Smith and Kelly
LeBrok. The film is about two 'nerdish' boys who use a computer to
create perfect women. Having created such a women on screen, she
magically appears in reality, and in one scene is shown holding up a
pair of undergarments and thinking allowed about what young boys
would like to see her wearing.

2. In a study that interviewed 854 male, female and transgender
prostitutes across 9 countries published in the Journal of Trauma
Practice, it was found that 70-95% of had been physically assaulted,
68% had post traumatic stress disorder, and the likelihood of early
death is 40% higher. 65% of interviewees had been sexually abused as
children.

3. Hook up is a term colloquially meaning to have sex.

 References

Angus, Thongs & Perfect Kissing (2008). Written and directed by
Gurinder Chadha

Anterburn & March (2007). Internet Protect Your Kids. Nashville.
Thomas Nelson

Barker M. (2011). 'De Beauvoir, Bridget Jones' Pants and Vaginismus'.
Existential Analysis 22.2. Journal of the Society for Existential
Analysis. London. BM Existential

Baudrillard, Jean (2009a). The Consumer Society: Myths & Structures.
London. Sage

Baudrillard, Jean (2009b). The Consumer Society: Myths & Structures.
Chapter 8, The Finest Consumer Object: The Body London. Sage

Bauman Z. (2007). Consuming Life. Chapter Three, Consumerist Culture,
page 82. Cambridge. Polity Press

Crichton (2000). Timeline. London. Arrow Books

Hanby, M (2005) The Culture of Death, the Ontology of Boredom, and
the Resistance of Joy. Communio (Summer 2004) pp 184-185; Quoted in
Casey M (2005), Strangers in the City, Chapter Four. Massachusetts.
Paraclete Press

Maimonides M (1963). The Guide of the Perplexed, Vol II. Pages
634-636. Chicago. University of Chicago Press

Roger C (1989). The Carl Rogers Reader. Chapter 28, Do we need a
reality. London. Constable

Spinelli, E. (2005). The Interpreted World: An Introduction to
Phenomenological Psychology. London. Sage

St. Trinnian's (2007). Directed by Oliver Parker with screen play by
Peirs Ashworth and Nick Moorcroft

Thorpe, V (2010). 'Why I wanted to win the bad Sex Award.' The
Observer Newspaper. 28th November. London

Urry, J (1990). The Tourist Gaze, Leisure and Travel in Contemporary
Societies. London. Sage.

Willig, Carla (2011). 'The Ethics of Interpretation' (Inaugural
Professorial Lecture). Existential Analysis 22.2, Journal of the
Society for Existential Analysis. London. BM Existential.

Yallom I (1980) Existential Psychotherapy. Chapter Four, page 110.
USA Basic Books

(c) Stephen Farthing 2011

E-mail: stephenfarthing@yahoo.co.uk


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Philosophy Pathways is the electronic newsletter for the
Pathways to Philosophy distance learning program

To subscribe or cancel your subscription please email your
request to philosophypathways@fastmail.net

The views expressed in this journal do not necessarily
reflect those of the editor. Contributions, suggestions or
comments should be addressed to klempner@fastmail.net
-----------------------------------------------------------------


[top]
Pathways to Philosophy

Original Newsletter
Home Page
Pathways Home Page